- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
  Awards and Recognition
  Bridge to Excellence
  Charter Schools
  Common Core State Standards
  Environmental Programs
  Equity Assurance
  ESEA Flexibility
  ESOL/Title III
  Family Literacy
  Financial Literacy
  Gifted and Talented
  Homeless Education Assistance
  Maryland Skills2Compete
  Military Families
  Multicultural Education
  No Child Left Behind
  Parent Involvement Matters Award
  Race to the Top
  Residential Education Program
  Response to Intervention
  School / Community Nutrition
  School Wellness Policy
     About Service-Learning
     Local School System Information
     Project Ideas
     Training Tools
     Program Evaluation Tools/ Quality Review
     Site Index
     Service-Learning Units
     Annual Service-Learning Recognition Event
     Preparation, Action, Reflection
     S-L Curriculum Materials
     Service-Learning Events
  STEM Education
  Teacher and Principal Evaluation
  Technology/Library Media
  Title I
  21st Century Learning Centers
Programs > Service-Learning
Program Evaluation Tools/ Quality Review

MSDE began a four-year cycle approach to monitoring and evaluating the quality of service-learning implementation in the local school systems.  In year one of the cycle, systems submit their detailed, written service-learning implementation plans to the MSDE.  A panel of stakeholders (students, teachers, administrators, community based organization representatives, MSDE and other government agency staff, etc.) review the documents and provide feedback to the local superintendents on the strengths of the program and potential areas of challenge.  In years 2-4, each system receives a Quality Review on site visit by MSDE staff.  The three Quality Review rubrics are used during the visit and a report highlighting strengths, challenges, and suggested next steps is sent to the local superintendent.


Quality Reviews are an opportunity to gain knowledge about service-learning programs and learn from one another about strategies and activities that work well.  The Maryland State Department of Education is always delighted to uncover effective approaches to service-learning and share those around the state as models for strengthening programs.

The one day visit will involve:

1)       A meeting with central office staff responsible for oversight of the service-learning program and any key staff that plays a role in program implementation (e.g. various content area specialists, etc.).  This meeting usually lasts one to two hours.

2)      Visits to preferably two schools that are representative of your service-learning program’s scope (e.g. one middle school and one high school, or an elementary school and middle school, etc.).  The school visit involves a meeting with school leadership for service-learning and then an opportunity to meet with teachers and students who have engaged in service-learning projects.   Each visit usually lasts one to two hours.  Please choose schools that we have not visited on previous Quality Review visits, if your system is large enough to accommodate that request.


NEW -- This cycle of reviews, we are asking local school systems to conduct a self assessment using the three Quality Review rubrics before the actual visit.  Those completed rubrics should be presented to reviewers when they arrive on the visit day.  Below are the three Quality Review rubrics.


In addition, if your school system is receiving Learn and Serve America funding, the Quality Review visit will act as an on-site visit for that program.  We ask that you have relevant documentation of grant status, particular regarding the budget, available when we meet.


Maryland’s 7 Best Practices Evaluation Tool – How effective is your service-learning project? How can you improve your project for next time?


Rubric for Assessing the Use of Maryland’s Seven Best Practices of Service-Learning A pdf version of the above Evaluation Tool.


Rubric for Assessing the Quality of School Service-Learning Leadership How effective is your school at implementing service-learning? How can your school’s service-learning leadership improve the implementation and support of service-learning?


Rubric for Assessing the Quality of LEA Service-Learning Leadership How effectively is your local school system implementing service-learning? How can your local school system improve the implementation and support of service-learning?

Contact Information
Julie Ayers, Service-Learning Specialist
Maryland State Department of Education
200 West Baltimore Street
Baltimore, MD 21201
Phone:   410-767-0358
Fax:   410-333-8010
Email:   jayers@msde.state.md.us
MSDE Privacy Statement Disclaimer  | Copyright © 2003 MSDE